Skip to main content

DebunkTheBIM: Dear building owners: we will let you know what you need to know when and how WE think you should get to know it!

DebunkTheBIM: Dear building owners: we will let you know what you need to know when and how WE think you should get to know it!

As a reaction to this post and venting some ideas on my own blog, I'd like to add some comments here.

I agree that most model viewers are very limited and only focus on 3D mesh + textures/color.
E.g. the Virtual Building Explorer (VBE) from Graphisoft (add-on for ArchiCAD) goes some way to make the design "viewable" by a user but don't expect the actual bulding information to be intact. It has gravity and collision detection (you can't walk through walls and you fall down when you pass an edge).

However, if you want, you can do a lot of that but you have to do it yourself... I happen to like Unity3D as a 3D realtime platform (and the free version goes a long way to do almost anything, apart from realtime shadows). But my remarks are not (too) software specific. Just that I will focus on things I know will work.

  • if you need north angles etc.. add some mesh objects to visualize that. This is possible with any software. In e.g. ArchiCAD, the quite flexible GDL library objects can be programmed so they orient themselves to north automatically. In an interactive environment, you could even program a small "HUD" (heads-up-display) which will draw the north angle as an overlay over your view, like the "radar" image in many shooting games does.
  • levels and spaces/zones are indeed mostly part of the 2D workflow. However, in e.g. ArchiCAD you have the option to render the spaces as 3D objects, which will enable them in any 3D model export you perform. The trick is now to ensure you can toggle spaces on and off in the viewer. In a out-of-the-box solution this is a problem, unless layers are user-togglable, but in a programmable environment you have control over this. You can even toggle an info dialog when users enter a space.
  • grids are also 2D, but with some clever 3D object, it might be viewable in 3D as well. But you have to take your audience into account, as this is not always useful information for them.
  • As far as visualizing design intent, I assume that you can get some way by making design variants and make separate visualizations or merge them in a single scene if you can toggle their visibility from within the viewer.
  • Tagging > as a flexible way to attach "any" info to "any" object, you can attach meaning to design objects. Now if viewers would have custom filters to display or hide objects based on their tags, you can get quite advanced additional visualization. I know that ArchiCAD supports markup highlights (color coding) on objects and you can create different views based on that info, but the same as with the previous remark: you have to find a way to provide this visibility to end users.
Understand that all these gripes are correct and to the point. I only wanted to point out some approaches to tackle at least some of them with current software.

I hope I can illustrate some of these points myself later on, with an interactive example...


Popular posts from this blog

Improve usage of BIM during early design phases

When I was collecting ideas for a book chapter on BIM (that seemed to never have emerged after that), I collected 10 ideas, which I believe still reflect good recommendations to improve the usage of BIM during the early design phases. These ideas are related to BIM software, but you can apply them in any flavor, as long as you can model with Building Elements, Spaces and have control over representation. Introduction This article gives an overview of several recommendations and tips, to better apply BIM applications and BIM methodologies, in the context of the early design phases. Many of these tips are applicable in any BIM application and they are based on experience gathered from teaching, researching and using BIM software. Sometimes they could help software developers to improve the workflow of their particular BIM implementation. Tip 1 : Gradually increase the amount of information In the early design phases, the architect makes assumptions and lays out the main design in

Getting BIM data into Unity (Part 9 - using IfcConvert)

This is part 9 of a series of posts about getting BIM data into Unity. In this post, we’ll discuss the IfcConvert utility from the IfcOpenShell Open Source IFC Library to preprocess an IFC model for integration with Unity. This is (finally?) again a coding post, with some scripts which are shared to build upon. Conversion of IFC into Unity-friendly formats The strategy with this approach is that you preprocess the IFC-file into more manageable formats for Unity integration. Most Web-platforms do some sort of pre-processing anyway, so what you see in your browsers is almost never an IFC-file, but an optimised Mesh-based geometric representation. However, it wouldn’t be BIM-related if we’d limit ourselves to the geometry, so we will parse the model information as well, albeit using another, pre-processed file. IFC to Wavefront OBJ I used a test IFC-model and used the IfcConvert-utility converted it into OBJ en XML formats. The default way to use it is very simple:

Getting BIM data into Unity (Part 8 - Strategies to tackle IFC)

This is part 8 of a series of posts about getting BIM data into Unity. In this post, we’ll discuss IFC as a transfer format towards Unity. As with the previous post, this is not a coding post, although hints and examples are provided. Open BIM and IFC Everybody who ever met me or heard me present on a conference or BIM-lecture will not be surprised to hear that I’m a strong believer in the Industry Foundation Classes (IFC), an open standard, with already two versions published as an ISO standard, being IFC2x2 and IFC4 (but surprisingly not IFC2x3 which is widely used). In the ideal world, this would be the format to use to transfer BIM data into another environment, such as Unity. So what are our options? Looking in the Unity Asset Store Assimp is a library which supports multiple formats, including IFC.   I did a few attempts, but alas without any success. It is possib